Blog this item

The Novice

(The Black Magician Trilogy, Book 2)

By Trudi Canavan

(95)

| Mass Market Paperback | 9780060575298

Like The Novice?
Join aNobii to see if your friends read it, and discover similar books!

Book Description

An epic trilogy of the magicians of Imardin, who gather each year to purge the city of undesirables. But a young girl penetrates their shield and secures a place in the MagiciansU Guild. Original. [예스24 제공]

2 Reviews

1 person find this helpful

2

Is this helpful?

bluetyson said on Mar 3, 2007 | Add your feedback

I am moderately satisfied with the series, though not with the first book.
What I think about each of the three books:
1) "The Guild": almost half of the book is spent relating the tentatives of Sonea, supported by a friend and the Thieves, to conceal herself from the Guild magicians: I ... (continue)

I am moderately satisfied with the series, though not with the first book.
What I think about each of the three books:
1) "The Guild": almost half of the book is spent relating the tentatives of Sonea, supported by a friend and the Thieves, to conceal herself from the Guild magicians: I think it is a waste of time and energy, because every reader undestands since a few pages that she's going to be captured and instructed from the Guild (it is impossible not to undestand it: the story is related also from some "good" magicians point of view an it would be of no use describing and introducing us with these magicians if they weren't going to be important characters in the rest of the book). Some thirty pages or so would have been enough to introduce us with the slums and the Thieves and a couple of characters coming through the whole series. Instead, one is just tempted to skip useless pages in order to go to the key events.
2) "The Novice": quite interesting the developing of Sonea's magical capabilities, satisfying the plot about her acceptance into the Guild. Flaw: unfortunately it is not concluded in itself, and it is absolutely necessary to read the third book.
3) "The High Lord": since now, the most appealing of the three books, a nice, well-paced plot (even if the Guild acts as a pretty stupid organism, blind fearful and dull-minded).
As a conclusion: I would give 1 star to the first book, and three stars to the other two.
The average would be less than two stars and a half, but I'm willing to give it three stars as a global evaluation because the story has quite a grip on the reader and, despite the series is far from perfect and the characters are sometimes a bit commonplace, one finds himself pleasurably driven forward.

Is this helpful?

Alice Bridgwater said on Aug 5, 2009 about the Paperback edition | Add your feedback