Blog this item

Mayflower

A Story of Courage, Community, and War

By Nathaniel Philbrick

(13)

| Hardcover | 9780670037605

Like Mayflower?
Join aNobii to see if your friends read it, and discover similar books!

Book Description

From the bestselling author of In the Heart of the Sea—winner of the National Book Award—the startling story of the Plymouth Colony

From the perilous ocean crossing to the shared bounty of the first Thanksgiving, the Pilgrim settlement of New England has become enshrinedContinue

Critics

New world, old woes

Mayflower: A Voyage to War by Nathaniel Philbrick 461pp, Harper Press, £20 All nations produce myths of their unique origins, and these are usually comforting. Along these lines, Americans celebrate Thanksgiving in late November. It's a cosy holiday, ... (read full critics)

guardian.co.uk published on Sat, 25 Sep 2010

The sins of the Pilgrim fathers

Mayflower: A Voyage to War by Nathaniel Philbrick HarperCollins, £20, pp480 History is at its most potent when the lessons of yesterday flow naturally into today. Here, brilliantly constructed, is a river of resonance. We have warlords and constantly ... (read full critics)

guardian.co.uk published on Sat, 25 Sep 2010

See all critics

2 Reviews

Goes a long way toward dispelling the myths that have surrounded the first English settlers and the Native peoples inhabiting New England. Rather than portraying the Pilgrim and Puritans as great heroes or absolute racist, murderous villians (as they have been since the 1960s), and visa versa for th ... (continue)

Goes a long way toward dispelling the myths that have surrounded the first English settlers and the Native peoples inhabiting New England. Rather than portraying the Pilgrim and Puritans as great heroes or absolute racist, murderous villians (as they have been since the 1960s), and visa versa for the Indians, Philbrick shows both sides as human, and how the failure to learn the lessons of the previous generation resulted in the bloody King Philip's War.

Is this helpful?

SWReader said on Oct 6, 2010 | Add your feedback

A great, mythbusting yarn

Many reviews I've seen of Mayflower criticize the author for (a) poor choice of book title, (b) shoddy history, (c) boring prose. The mixed reviews on this prevented me from purchasing the book for quite some time, until curiosity got the better of me. While little can be said abo ... (continue)

Many reviews I've seen of Mayflower criticize the author for (a) poor choice of book title, (b) shoddy history, (c) boring prose. The mixed reviews on this prevented me from purchasing the book for quite some time, until curiosity got the better of me. While little can be said about whether a book is boring or not (to each his own), I'd advise those lamenting the book's title to start reading labels - it was very clear on the back cover (you didn't even need to crack the book) what this story was about. Similarly, to those self-proclaimed historians - get out of the pop-history aisle and start buying textbooks. Nowhere does Philbrick claim to be a professional historian; he is a writer and journalist, and having recently finished Mayflower I feel that his 2007 Pulitzer nomination was well-deserved... Mayflower is a crackin' good read. In the prologue Philbrick makes it clear that he uses not only standard sources for his story, but also oral history & traditions from the Native Americans of the region in an attempt to tell a balanced story of the first settlers in Plymouth, their struggles, their successes and failures, and the ultimate unravelling of what had been delicately created through the bias and shortsightedness of subsequent generations culminating in "King Phillip's War". This bias and shortsightedness can be claimed by both sides, although Philbrick levels a larger portion at the English/Pilgrims/Puritans - choose your label - and, for my money, he backs it up nicely. What makes Puritan culpability more believable is that we see the same mistakes being made today by arguably better educated and more world-wise governments. Mayflower isn't all roses. I would like to have seen Philbrick spend a little more time on some of the better known aspects of the Pilgrim national myth - the time in England and Holland, the first Thanksgiving, etc. - but the story doesn't suffer for it. In fact, I would have welcomed another 50 pages, or so, in such a well-written book. All said, I found Mayflower to be a great read - exposing time-honored myths in a believable way that does not diminish the accomplishments of the passengers of that ship one iota. Removing the romantic patina that's built up over the years allows us to appreciate the story more - warts and all. Maybe we can even learn something from this...

Is this helpful?

Andyberschauer said on Mar 11, 2009 about the Paperback edition | Add your feedback