• 1 of 1 person find this helpful

  • A Strange Tale

  • The subject of this book (scent) is very intriguing. It's an easy sense to disregard and it certainly made me think of smell in a different way. This book came highly recommended, but I don't see what the fuss is about really.

    I had a problem with the sarcastic, almost humorous tone of the nar ... Continue

    The subject of this book (scent) is very intriguing. It's an easy sense to disregard and it certainly made me think of smell in a different way. This book came highly recommended, but I don't see what the fuss is about really.

    I had a problem with the sarcastic, almost humorous tone of the narrator. I feel like the story could have been so much more if it had been told in a serious manner. We never really get inside the villain's head because of this.

    Grenouille himself is difficult to describe. He really had no human characteristics at all (besides arrogance). His keen bloodhound smell is interesting, but seems illogical. Overall, his character is not very believable and that's why the story doesn't work for me.

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― MoirneStark said on Jun 24, 2008 about the Paperback edition| Add your feedback

• 1 of 1 person find this helpful

  • My thoughts

  • Jean-Baptiste Grenouille - human or monster? Both? Just when I found myself feeling sympathetic to this young man who grew up without human kindness, the monster side of him would emerge and I could sense his scorn for people he fooled with his pretense of humanity. This was a beautifully written bo ... Continue

    Jean-Baptiste Grenouille - human or monster? Both? Just when I found myself feeling sympathetic to this young man who grew up without human kindness, the monster side of him would emerge and I could sense his scorn for people he fooled with his pretense of humanity. This was a beautifully written book about the importance of smell that we all take for granted and how one man with an incredible gift took advantage of people.

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― krin5292 said on Sep 13, 2007 about the Paperback edition| Add your feedback

Groups with this in collection

Malaysian Bookworms (36)

50 Book Challenge! (296)

Historical Fiction Lovers (111)

• 501 Must read books1001 books to read before you dieFranceHistorical FictionTo-Readliteraturewith methrillerfictionMy favorites