has ALL you need!

A community for book lovers to create their own bookshelves, share and explore books.

Google Preview

• 1 person find this helpful

  • *** This comment contains spoilers! ***
  • 

  • You must know that I bought this book mostly because I sorta of knew the author, that was pretty famous in the HP fanfiction world and I definitely loved her writing style from the very second I put my eyes on DV's trilogy.

    So, encouraged by my optimism, I finally made up my mind and I got my ... Continue

    You must know that I bought this book mostly because I sorta of knew the author, that was pretty famous in the HP fanfiction world and I definitely loved her writing style from the very second I put my eyes on DV's trilogy.

    So, encouraged by my optimism, I finally made up my mind and I got my copy at Borders, whilts I was in Melbourne this summer, though I've seen it around even here in Italy (but by now you know what I think about translations, do you?). This it the first book of the Mortal Instruments Trilogy, where we start to know the universe of Shadowhunters, so you have to approach it with this clearly into your mind: you won't be able to appreciate the whole story unitl you'll read the very last line of the third book. That's the first thing I've learned about the author, so this is a sort of free advice.

    Anyway, since this is the first book of a trilogy and we live in a world where things goes on only if they make you earn a lot of money, I can easily say that they story sort of close itself, allowing it almost to be a standing-alone book.

    Almost.

    Going on speaking of the story, without being too much spoilerish, I can tell you it has both good original peaks and some already seen around.

    The original peaks are about all the Shadowhunters world, the explanation about how demons are flowing into our world and all the difference between mundandes (regular people), Shadowhunters and Downworlders (Vampires, faeries, etc). I definitely like all the runes related stuff and how the reality seems splitted in three parallels systems... that they aren't parallel at all, but strongly mixed into heach other, but that still seems so far away, like we are talking of different worlds instead of Earth.

    The stuff already seen, instead, it's mostly related to character development. Clary, the main character, is beautifully portraied: she's a young teen-ager that grows up through the book: starts as a naive girl, she finds love and then she has her first real fight against reality and the hardness of things. And we can see her react to situations quite realistically, besides the fact that she's a bit reckless (but if it wasn't the case, we wouldn't have any story XD). The only flaw about this character is her best friend, Simon. The VERY BEST FRIEND EVER, he has all the right reactions, the supportive side and even when he starts to realize that the love of his life loves someone else, he faced it pretty well. You know, there aren't many people like this around and suddenly it happens that there are two of them in the same city, in the same circle of friends?! I'm referring to Luke and Simon, if you were wondering... and if I can believe this behavior from Luke, that is an adult, it's quite hard to accept from a teen.

    And then Jace. Or should I call him Cassie!Draco? At the beginning I thought it was just a bad impression of mine, but when he told Clary the falcon story and when we were introduced to Valentine (the copy of Cassie!Lucius), the resemblance was too evident to be discharged. Not that this is a bad thing, because I always thought she did a brilliant work with those two character in DV: they were brilliant and vivid, with their flaws and smartness and the same applies to Jace and Valentine. Jace is amazing, always on the edge of becaming an unbelievable Mary-Sue and then, suddenly, he does something that destroy all that perfect aura, leaving just the boy behind the façade. Sure, he's the clear stereotype of the hero, beautiful and strong, always head down in danger... but there's even his humanity that comes out, the strangeness habits and traits (like his monk-like room) and his hunger of always be the best.

    Valentine, as I told above, reminds me strongly of Cassie!Lucius and this is even better, because I've always thought that he was probably the best charcater out of DV. And Valentine seems quite amazing even here, even if it remembers me too much of Voldemort&Death Eaters from Harry Potter's series, which is the bad thing about him... because I can accept a resemblance to a character you invented (and, besides the same name, I can assure you all that Cassie!Lucius was completely hers), but not to someone elses'.

    But besides that, this is a good book. Description are good, in enough amount, and well mixed with the story... actually, they are what makes the whole story believable. I appreciated how the author stands and describes a city she deeply knows, instead of going for a foreigner setting, that would sound more exotic but harder to handle. And when she has to move things in a different place, it's somewhere that actually doesn't exists. I also appreciated how she refers to Idris, because it reminded me of Dante's pleas during his exile, how he portrayed his city, Firenze, as both the perfect and worse place in the world.

    It was definitely good the work she made with the different cultures (mundane vs shadowhunters) and how often they clashes to each other, because they had backgrounds and references that don't mix together. I laugh a lot, for instance, when Jace quoted Blake and Clary recognized it, but only because it's a line from a Doors' song. And she never misses a beats about this aspect, neither when the plot jump and take a faster pace. This shows only attention to what she's doing, which should make the reader grateful.

    About her writing style, it definitely improved and I noticed she is still experimenting with POV switching, even if not always the final results is good... I'm referring to a peculiar point of the book, at the very beginning of chapter 18, when suddenly we are in Jace head and a page an a half later we are back full force to Clary's POV. That sounded definitely wrong to me, really.

    The last thing I want to talk about is the major themes affronted into the book, that didn't sound to me good for a young audience. I don't know in other countries, but here in Italy the books are sold in the children section! And there are themes portrayed in the book that aren't surely suitable for a younger audience... actually, I don't even think that most of the kids around Clary's age wouldn't be able to completely understand what's going on with Clary and Jace, what are the deeper implications and why they are so desperate. It's actually surprising coming even from them too, but I guess that in that case it's the author speaking, not her characters. All in all, I would even thought of older characters (not too much older, 3/4 years would be fine), to make the whole ordeal more believable, but this is just me I guess.

    Anyway, the final conclusion about everything is this one: read this book, read it AS A BOOK and enjoy the story. It's worth of trying, even if my general observations still stands and probably most of you will notice them during reading.

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― Esus said on Oct 11, 2008 about the Paperback edition| Add your feedback

• .

  • Great book!!! Has a surprise in the end, nt sure if i liked that though

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― Elina Debbie said on Sep 24, 2009 about the Paperback edition| Add your feedback

• .

  • 

  • Recensito qui: http://cosanepenso.wordpress.com/2009/07/02/cit...

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― Hallgerðr said on Jul 3, 2009 | Add your feedback

• .

  • If you dislike Bella from Twilight...

  • You'll probably also not care for Clary in this book, haha. She's not as whiny but still pretty stupid and annoying. All of the writing in this book is pretty annoying, actually. This book is over-filled with similes, poor descriptions, stupid character names, characters that think they are much ... Continue

    You'll probably also not care for Clary in this book, haha. She's not as whiny but still pretty stupid and annoying. All of the writing in this book is pretty annoying, actually. This book is over-filled with similes, poor descriptions, stupid character names, characters that think they are much wittier than they actually are, and a predictable storyline.

    Despite all of that, there is a little bit of fun in here too, however it gets really bogged down from all of the above problems. I wasn't going to bother reading the next book in the series, but now I find myself thinking... well.... maybe..... :)

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― Deanna Kyre said on Apr 29, 2009 | Add your feedback

• .

  • City of Bones

  • I didn't really care for the first 11 chapters, but once past that point the book moved rather quickly for me. The fore-shadowing was fairly heavy handed so I wasn't much surprised by the "big plot twist" but I still enjoyed the story enough to give the next installment in the series a shot.

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― Readingrat said on Aug 25, 2008 | Add your feedback

• .

  • *** This comment contains spoilers! ***
  • The ending sucked!

  • How can they make them brother and sister?! THEY MADE OUT WITH EACH OTHER FOR CRYING OUT LOUD! It was good till they turned out to be siblings...but I still can't wait for the next one...who knows, maybe its just something Valentine is plotting! (Cause I REALLY hope it is)

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― Thekygurl said on Mar 1, 2008 | Add your feedback

Their hidden world is about to be revealed....

When fifteen-year-old Clary Fray heads out to the Pandemonium Club in New York City, she hardly expects to witness a murder -- much less a murder committed by three teenagers covered with strange tattoos and brandishing bizarre weapons. Clary knows she should call the police, but it's hard to explain a murder when the body disappears into thin air and the murderers are invisible to everyone but Clary.

Equally startled by her ability to see them, the murderers explain themselves as Shadowhunters: a secret tribe of warriors dedicated to ridding the earth of demons. Within twenty-four hours, Clary's mother disappears and Clary herself is almost killed by a grotesque demon. But why would demons be interested in ordinary mundanes like Clary and her mother? And how did Clary suddenly get the Sight? The Shadowhunters would like to know....

Groups with this in collection

book recommendations (86)

Shadowhunters- The Mortal Instruments (106)

• RomanziMortal InstrumentsJuvenil RománticaFantasiaCe l'hoStranieriFANTASY英文小說shadowhuntersLike...Harry Potter
• See all (40)