Like Dombey and Son?
Join aNobii to see if your friends read it, and discover similar books!
Book Description
Dombey and Son is both a family and a firm and this ambiguity is at the heart of Dickens's novel. For Mr Dombey pride of position and mercantile reputation are gods to which all human feelings must be sacrificed ... Dickens is attempting something new in English fiction, to look beyond isolated erroContinue
2 Reviews
-
Robot-mel said on Nov 27, 2010 about the Audio Cassette edition | Add your feedback
-
guaddess said on May 31, 2007 about the Paperback edition | Add your feedback
Book Details
-
Rating:
(20)
-
5 stars
-
4 stars
-
3 stars
-
2 stars
-
1 star
-
5 stars
- English Books
- Mass Market Paperback 992 Pages
- Publisher: Penguin Books
- Pub date: Jan 01, 1970
- Also available as: Paperback, Hardcover, Audio Cassette, Library Binding, Others and eBook
- In other languages: other languages
Prices Change currency & sellers
| ISBN | Edition | List | Sale | Seller |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No ISBN | Mass Market Paperback | -- | -- | -- |
| Other editions → | ||||
mattypenny 
I feel like I can now quite safely say I do not care at all for Dickens! This was my third (and probably final) attempt at liking one of his novels. It was recommended to me by people who also don't normally like him so I thought it'd be my best chance and there were indeed some parts I did like.
I ... (continue)
I feel like I can now quite safely say I do not care at all for Dickens! This was my third (and probably final) attempt at liking one of his novels. It was recommended to me by people who also don't normally like him so I thought it'd be my best chance and there were indeed some parts I did like.
I liked Paul and Florence as children, there was one description of Paul at school as an old alchemical text which I thought was brilliant. I liked Florence and Edith when they were grown up. Indeed the only way I could make it through the secound half was imagining all sorts of femslash between Edith and Florence - who loved each other so much - and I just really wanted the two of them to run away together.
I had two huge problems with the book. One the unbearably cartoonish/caricture charcters. Captain Cuttle, Bagstock, Mr Dombey, Miss Tonks etc. They were just so far removed from actual people they just made the whole thing seem like a farce. It totally removed any of the feeling and depth to the story because it was far too ridiculous to be remotely plausible.
The other problem I had was that nothing really happened. While I don't have a problem with that in books that have great characterisation, here it was almost unbearable. People met and had idiotic conversations and left to disapear for a few chapters then come back and something similar would happen.
I must admit with only a few exceptional sentences I didn't care at all for Dickens prose. Normally I love the Victorian style of writing, but compared to most of the authors I like he just writes like an exceptional verbose children's book.
So no more Dickens for me. At least not for a few years. There are so many Victorian authors I do love and would rather be reading those.
Is this helpful?