Blog this item

Mother Tongue

The English Language

By Bill Bryson

(81)

| Paperback | 9780140143058

Like Mother Tongue?
Join aNobii to see if your friends read it, and discover similar books!

Critics

Bill Bryson – Mother Tongue

Chris Mitchell Mother Tongue - Bill Bryson See all books by Bill Bryson at Amazon.co.uk | Amazon.com Mother Tongue is one of Bill Bryson's earlier books and a superbly manageable and amusing treatise on the English language - where it came from, what ... (read full critics)

spikemagazine published on Tue, 14 Sep 2010

6 Reviews

6 people find this helpful

Interesting look at languages, esp English

I read his "A Short History of Nearly Everything" before picking up this one. Bill Bryson, as always, has written an interesting book to further our understandings on some of the most mundance subjects.
Unfortunately, like the other book, this book is plagued by small factual errors, which und ... (continue)

I read his "A Short History of Nearly Everything" before picking up this one. Bill Bryson, as always, has written an interesting book to further our understandings on some of the most mundance subjects.
Unfortunately, like the other book, this book is plagued by small factual errors, which undermines the credibility of the rest of the probably accurate and definitely well laid out discourse. I am no expert in language, but I'm a native speaker of Cantonese (a dialect of Chinese). I can't help but notice that nearly everything he says about the Chinese language is fundamentally wrong.
Nonetheless, there are a lot of useful and humorous insights on the English language in this book, and I'd probably move on to A Walk in the Woods, which was recommended to me by some friends as Bryson's best work.

Is this helpful?

s tsui said on Oct 25, 2006 | 1 feedback

2 people find this helpful

Good, but not great

I really enjoyed this book, an entertaining and humous look at the origins of the English language, its various dialects and the roles other languages have played in giving it such a diverse selection of words and spelilings. The reasons why ough has so many different ways of being pronounced, and t ... (continue)

I really enjoyed this book, an entertaining and humous look at the origins of the English language, its various dialects and the roles other languages have played in giving it such a diverse selection of words and spelilings. The reasons why ough has so many different ways of being pronounced, and the reasons behind much of the illogical aspects of English.
Despite the good points I was a little disapointed in this book.
It seemed very dated, which in itself is not something I can really criticise it for, after all I doubt even Bryson can tell the future. Maybe it is just that I enjoyed his other books so much that this was a bit of a let down. And of course he says in the book that he doesn't see any future for the Irish language past the start of the next century, so that was four years ago. And afaik Irish seemd to be going from strenth to strength. Of course it is still a minority language, but irish names are now hugely popular, not just among the D4-ers. Irish is becoming more and more part of eeryday life, just take a look at today fm's gift grub sketches; Radio Roy as gaeilge is a fav of mine, but even the quiz with Coilín Farrell is amusing.
Níl alán gaeilge agam, agus tá mo litriú úfaiseach (mar a dúirt Bosco), ach tá suim agam san teanga.
Not only does he say it is a dying language, but he describes it as gaelic (irish), but the only examples of gaelic he seems to use in the book are Scottish, which although similar is different.
But that is not really why I wasn't too impressed with this book. It is the inaccuracies such as describing an English accent! Now there is as much an English accent as there is an Irish one, that is there isn't one. The accent he was talking about, was, I think the BBC or upperclass accent. But the majority of British people do not speak like that, even those without a strong regional accent are more likely to have a slight hint of their area and not the "english accent."
So I did enjoy the book, it has Bryson's usual humour but I wasn't as impressed as I thought I would be

Is this helpful?

Dee said on Jul 20, 2007 | Add your feedback

1 person find this helpful

So many factual errors.

Is this helpful?

Luca said on Jan 30, 2010 | Add your feedback

Inaccurate and outdated

I had enjoyed "Made in America" so much that I had great expectations for "Mother Tongue" as well... I was really disappointed instead. So many inaccuracies about Italian and other languages I know raise doubts about the accuracy of the rest. The book was published about two decades ago, and in some ... (continue)

I had enjoyed "Made in America" so much that I had great expectations for "Mother Tongue" as well... I was really disappointed instead. So many inaccuracies about Italian and other languages I know raise doubts about the accuracy of the rest. The book was published about two decades ago, and in some parts it feels so terribly outdated - it would be very interesting to compare the last chapter's data on Hispanic presence in the US with this year's census!

Is this helpful?

ary29 said on Nov 18, 2010 | Add your feedback

Entertaining Stories About Language

Entertaining book on English and languages in general. Bryson is his characteristic self: amusing and informed.
I marked this book down one star because I had the feeling that Bryson's facts were a bit dubious. I have since googled this and it seems there are many people who think the book is ... (continue)

Entertaining book on English and languages in general. Bryson is his characteristic self: amusing and informed.
I marked this book down one star because I had the feeling that Bryson's facts were a bit dubious. I have since googled this and it seems there are many people who think the book is a little flimsy on the facts. He apparently relies too easily on folk etymology (ordinary people's opinion about the origin of words) which is very entertaining but not correct from a linguistic or factual sense.
I found the chapter dealing with languages like Chinese one of the most fascinating only to learn that some native speakers thought Bryson's "facts" about Chinese to be very inaccurate!
Still, a very entertaining book (four stars!) but beware that Bryson is no linguist and while very amusing and enjoyable, his stories about language need to be taken with a large dose of scepticism! The book is, however, a very fun starting point for anyone exploring language as an exciting subject.
Perhaps the most important aspect of this book for me was how it did shed light on the constant development and change in English. Rules of grammar today were not there yesterday, and yesterday's rules are often discarded. No-one who reads a book like this can ever again be confident that there is one and only one "correct" usage or spelling in English - language changes constantly and we sometimes need to relax on the "correctness" of things in case we miss out on the creative opportunities presented by bending the rules a little. Or a lot. Much of what is English today started out as slang, a mistake, or pure invention (as in the case of Shakespeare who invented more words out of thin air than anyone!).
Highly recommended for its entertainment value.
The paperback binding of this edition is nothing special, the paper average pulp quality, though not prone to cracking the glued spine if due care is taken.

Is this helpful?

Ramnagel said on Jul 4, 2009 | Add your feedback