• 1 of 1 person find this helpful

  • 

  • In today's society we already have surrogate mothers, why not surrogate organ doners? A compelling story of a possible future. What made me saddest was the fact they were raised in schools as normal children. Where upon graduation, shuffled of to "camps" to live until they had been taught what th ... Continue

    In today's society we already have surrogate mothers, why not surrogate organ doners? A compelling story of a possible future. What made me saddest was the fact they were raised in schools as normal children. Where upon graduation, shuffled of to "camps" to live until they had been taught what they're responsibilities really were. Seems wrong to do that. After all they, were humans, cloned or not.

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― Helena said on Jul 14, 2007 about the Hardcover edition| Add your feedback

• .

  • Proceed with Caution

  • I was thoroughly engaged in this book and really didn't put it down unless I had to. But it did leave me feeling unsatisfied, heartbroken. I quickly needed to read something else more uplifting afterward.

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― Raquel (eraquel) said on Apr 14, 2008 about the Paperback edition| Add your feedback

• 1 of 2 people find this helpful

  • Suprise!

  • Like many of Ishiguro's books, this is not so much about the actual storyline of the book, but about the characters of the book. We are encouraged to sympathize and think with characters about life and human nature. But the odd nonchalant treatment of the plot, which could just as easily been foun ... Continue

    Like many of Ishiguro's books, this is not so much about the actual storyline of the book, but about the characters of the book. We are encouraged to sympathize and think with characters about life and human nature. But the odd nonchalant treatment of the plot, which could just as easily been found in a scifi book, was distracting. I wanted to find out more about the purpose of the school the children attended and those who began and ran the program they were in.
    I am sure others liked this book. It was insightful and left me thinking. But it just wasn't my flavor.

    

    Is this helpful?

• ― KyotoCutie said on Mar 28, 2007 about the Hardcover edition| Add your feedback

Groups with this in collection

Worldcon 2007 (2)

50 Book Challenge! (296)

Eclectic Book Club (97)

• Books I Want to Readwish listTahoe1001 books to read before you diefictioncontemporaryContemporary litNovelDystopiaMy favorites
• See all (13)