Blog this item

The Cult of the Amateur

How today's Internet is killing our culture

By Andrew Keen

(18)

| Hardcover | 9780385520805

Like The Cult of the Amateur?
Join aNobii to see if your friends read it, and discover similar books!

Book Description

From Publishers Weekly
Keen's relentless "polemic" is on target about how a sea of amateur content threatens to swamp the most vital information and how blogs often reinforce one's own views rather than expand horizons. But his jeremiad about the death of "our cultural standards and moral values" heads swiftly downhill. Keen became somewhat notorious for a 2006 Weekly Standard essay equating Web 2.0 with Marxism; like Karl Marx, he offers a convincing overall critique but runs into trouble with the details. Readers will nod in recognition at Keen's general arguments—sure, the Web is full of "user-generated nonsense"!—but many will frown at his specific examples, which pretty uniformly miss the point. It's simply not a given, as Keen assumes, that Britannica is superior to Wikipedia, or that record-store clerks offer sounder advice than online friends with similar musical tastes, or that YouTube contains only "one or two blogs or songs or videos with real value." And Keen's fears that genuine talent will go unnourished are overstated: writers penned novels before there were publishers and copyright law; bands recorded songs before they had major-label deals. In its last third, the book runs off the rails completely, blaming Web 2.0 for online poker, child pornography, identity theft and betraying "Judeo-Christian ethics." (June)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

Review

What the experts are saying about Andrew Keen’s thought-provoking polemic

“My initial reaction to the book was: ‘Geez, I have a lot of things to think about now.’ For people immersed in the social communities of Web 2.0, this is bound to be a thought-provoking and sobering book. While I don't agree with everything Keen says, there is page after page of really interesting insight and research. I look forward to the much-needed debate about the problems that Keen articulates—which can't be lightly dismissed.”
—Larry Sanger, co-founder, Wikipedia and founder, Citizendium

“Marvelous and provocative . . . . I think this is a powerful stop and breathe book in the midst of the obsessions and abstraction of folks seeking comfort in Web 2.0. Beautifully written too.”
—Chris Schroeder, former CEO, WashingtonPost/Newsweek online and CEO, Health Central Network

“Important . . . will spur some very constructive debate. This is a book that can produce positive changes to the current inertia of web 2.0.
—Martin Green, vice president of community, CNET

“For anyone who thinks that technology alone will make for a better democracy, Andrew Keen will make them think twice.”
—Andrew Rasiej, founder, Personal Democracy Forum

“Very engaging, and quite controversial and provocative. He doesn’t hold back any punches.”
—Dan Farber, editor-in-chief, ZDNet

“Andrew Keen is a brilliant, witty, classically-educated technoscold—and thank goodness. The world needs an intellectual Goliath to slay Web 2.0's army of Davids.”
—Jonathan Last, online editor, The Weekly Standard

[강컴닷컴 제공]

Critics

The Cult of the Amateur

Keen was once a Silicon Valley entrepreneur, but has since undergone a Damascene conversion and now views the so-called Web 2.0 of YouTube, MySpace, Wikipedia and millions of blogs as culturally corrosive. This is a celebration of traditional media a ... (read full critics)

guardian.co.uk published on Fri, 24 Sep 2010

Fretting about the internet

In its early days, the telephone was expected to be of most use in listening to musical concerts. If it had been, it would hardly have done much harm, despite its acoustic shortcomings: more people would have been attracted to live performances, havi ... (read full critics)

spectator published on Fri, 17 Sep 2010

See all critics

4 Reviews

2 people find this helpful

Andrew Keen Interview

I don't agree with everything is on this book, but I sincerely believe we need more books like this to fully appreciate the extent, dangers, and consequences of the web2.0 revolution.
On July 13, 2007 I had the pleasure and the honor to interview Andrew Keen for the Novedge blog. Here is the l ... (continue)

I don't agree with everything is on this book, but I sincerely believe we need more books like this to fully appreciate the extent, dangers, and consequences of the web2.0 revolution.
On July 13, 2007 I had the pleasure and the honor to interview Andrew Keen for the Novedge blog. Here is the link:
http://blog.novedge.com/2007/07/an-interview--2.html

Is this helpful?

Franco Folini said on Jul 9, 2007 | Add your feedback

1 person find this helpful

Thought-provoking & short-sighted.
While there are quite a few good ideas in there, it seems tainted by nonsense such as "every single song download is a lost album sale", and "amateur music and videos on YouTube and MySpace are entirely to blame for every music and video store that closes". ... (continue)

Thought-provoking & short-sighted.
While there are quite a few good ideas in there, it seems tainted by nonsense such as "every single song download is a lost album sale", and "amateur music and videos on YouTube and MySpace are entirely to blame for every music and video store that closes". Of course, these statements are preposterous, and it is quite unfortunate that Mr. Keen feels the need to hide behind these, because otherwise, he brings interesting ideas to the table.

Is this helpful?

ericsamson said on Sep 21, 2008 | Add your feedback

Disappointing

There are many problems with the current rhetorics and practices of "Internet culture", but getting rid of the "good old times" is not one of them. Unfortunately, that's all this book seems to be obsessed with.

Is this helpful?

Andrea said on Jan 23, 2012 | Add your feedback