Prima di tutto e un libro mooolto lungo, anche se alla fine capisci che la struttura della storia lo necessita.
La parte finale è veramente molto intensa e la scrittrice è eccezionale nel gettarti in mezzo alla disperazione e a darti la sensazione che non vi è via di uscita.
Niente colpi di scena o guarigioni miracolose.
La peste uccide.
... e il passaggio da karvin a santa Caterina è davvero stupefacente.
Sono contento di aver letto questo libro
I was engrossed the whole time I was reading. The characters are strong and the plot brilliantly imagined. I really appreciate Willis' attention to detail and her patience in telling the two stories. The descriptions of the plague are extremely powerful (and disturbing). It really makes you consider the destruction and the suffering that a single disease can cause. In Colin's words: it's "apocalyptic."...Continua
In the year 2525, there are women… sorry, about that interuption from Cleopatra 2525, it was really out of place, considering that this book isn’t even set in 2525, but in the year 2054, when historians could travel back in time to really study their subjects. Kivrin is one such historian. But she doesn’t want to travel to the C20th, where most historians are sent, she wants to be the first to travel back to the Medieval period. And she succeeds in her aim, but something isn’t quite right. No one can ever be entirely certain as to where or when a historian will end up. A certain amount of slippage always occurs. But in Kivrin’s case her tech falls ill and so her fate is even more uncertain.
Waiting for her in 2054 is Mr. Dunworthy, her tutor, a man who never wanted her to travel back so far. There was plague and robbers and cut-throats and almost uncountable ways to die back then. But the the Medieval department at Oxford decide to send her anyway. Without what Mr Dunworthy considers as enough tests.
I really enjoyed this book. It is one you want to keep on reading, not addictively so, I didn’t stay up half the night because I needed to finish just one more chapter, but I did read it in chunks rather than flitting in for a chapter or two. At first the historical part was the more interesting to me, I wanted to find out how Kivrin was getting on in C14th England, but I was soon just as entertained by the future story, with the flu that threatens Oxford and the resulting quarantine. Of course having the two diseases in different times also allows the reader to see certain parallels between the two societies. The beaurocracy of the future against the ignorance of the past. Neither comes out as perfect but neither is villified. Both make mistakes, just in different ways.
I also really liked the characters. Kivrin was a tad on the annoying side in her “I know all the dangers but want to go” but she was still fun to read about. And Mr Dunworthy with his constant worries about her. The characters from the C14th were more supporting characters than main ones, but they were still all individuals and it was easy to imagine back stories and histories for them.
The one thing I did find that hit a wrong note was the way Oxford in the future actually seemed quite old-fashioned. With talk of trunk calls and spectacles, and sisters in the hospitals. Plus the lack of mobile phones really dates it. Still those are minor quibbles that can easily be ignored....Continua