hao1022
25

Reviews

0

Quotations

0

Notes

hao1022

Taiwan

Anobian since Mar 5, 2008

0Following2Followers
No Books

Now Reading

hao1022's Activity

hao1022
hao1022 added to library

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 added to library
一本讀懂人類圖
by Karen Curry, 凱倫.柯瑞
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)(7)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Review

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Review

hao1022
hao1022 rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
過一個歡樂的宋朝新年
by 李開周
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(35)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
過一個歡樂的宋朝新年
by 李開周
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(35)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 added to library
過一個歡樂的宋朝新年
by 李開周
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(35)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 wrote a review
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
Spoiler Alert
略有缺憾,但仍為精彩佳作!
寫這本書以前,東野圭吾已經撰寫推理小說超過十年了,出版作品無數,不得不說他毅力驚人,儘管前期作品沒有受到大眾廣泛討論,仍然寫作不輟。 整體來說,這本書有帶出推理小說的那種詭譎、不安、恐懼的氛圍,劇情推展速度也恰到好處,值得推薦,但是,有些瑕疵之處仍然讓人覺得這不是一部成熟的推理小說...... 無論是不是推理小說,在寫作過程難免會為了情節的高潮起伏而不斷埋下伏筆,然後在之後的推展過程中一一解開,引動讀者心中的震撼與情緒,推理小說解開伏筆的過程尤其重要,推理是否合理,會影響讀者對這部小說的「取信」程度,它就像是個猜謎遊戲,謎底掀開以後故事就結束了,也很難讓人重回「無知」的時刻重猜一次,所以推理小說的趣味在於一氣呵成,不讓讀者在過程中「跳出」,謎底固然重要,但如何帶讀者走到謎底所在之處,就是推理作家的功力了。 然而這本書的推理過程有滿多漏洞的,兩位主角的推理時常沒有嚴密的邏輯,例如有一段,男主角看到玄關掛著海景的畫,就覺得這畫有問題,原因是這棟房子不靠海,但只有靠海才能掛海景畫嗎?這個推理會不會太腦補了?有不少類似的邏輯問題在這部小說裡面反覆出現,導致我在看書的時候不斷「跳出」。故事發展到後面,主角才驚覺自己的推理有先入為主的問題,成功的推理作品應該要把讀者拉到跟主角一樣的位置,跟主角一起猜謎、同喜同悲,但我作為一個讀者,早就發現邏輯的問題,已經走得比主角更快了,就沒有辦法非常進入劇情。 在人物塑造的部分,主要是挖掘女主角的幼年記憶,但前段也有帶出一些男主角自己的事情,那個部分作者應該也有在鋪梗,甚至讓我懷疑是不是男主角小時候也跟女主角有接觸,但故事到最後都沒有去進一步闡述。如果那個部分不是重點,那就不該有過多的鋪陳,如果已經鋪陳了,就要去解決。 雖然作品有些瑕疵,但我仍然會想持續關注東野圭吾的作品,能不斷堅持寫作、投注熱情,相信時間會給予回饋的。 後記:我後來看評論才知道,這本著作其實不是2015的作品,而是東野圭吾的前期作品,既然如此,後續更值得期待了!
hao1022
hao1022 added to library
以前,我死去的家
by 東野圭吾
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(274)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
以前,我死去的家
by 東野圭吾
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(274)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
以前,我死去的家
by 東野圭吾
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(274)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 added to library
以前,我死去的家
by 東野圭吾
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(274)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 added to library
从前我死去的家
by 東野圭吾
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(274)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
我們不要忘記今天
by 申京淑
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)(17)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

hao1022
hao1022 rated
(*)(*)( )( )( )
企業Bee修課
by 查爾斯.戴克
(*)(*)(*)( )( )(3)

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

Review

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

Review

hao1022
hao1022 added to library
企業Bee修課
by 查爾斯.戴克
(*)(*)(*)( )( )(3)

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

Review

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

Review