Lai
28

Reviews

0

Quotations

0

Notes

Lai

Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR China

Anobian since Jul 23, 2010

1Following2Followers
No Books

Now Reading

Lai's Activity

Lai
Lai rated
(*)( )( )( )( )
香港二十八總督
by 張連興
(*)(*)(*)( )( )(6)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Lai
Lai rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
活著
by 余華 
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)(1,833)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Lai
Lai rated
(*)(*)(*)( )( )
歷史的沉重
by 王宏志
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)(15)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Review

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Review

Lai
Lai rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
真實的貧窮面貌
by 周永新
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(3)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Review

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Review

Lai
Lai rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
200年日本史
by 安德魯.戈登 Andrew Gordon
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)(5)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Lai
Lai rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
200年日本史
by 安德魯.戈登 Andrew Gordon
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)(5)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Lai
Lai rated
(*)(*)(*)( )( )
牛津通識 民族主義
by Steven Grosby
(*)(*)(*)( )( )(1)

Has it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Has it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Lai
Lai rated
(*)(*)(*)( )( )
群力勝天
by 姚穎嘉
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(3)

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Lai
Lai rated
(*)(*)(*)( )( )
群力勝天
by 姚穎嘉
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(3)

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Lai
Lai rated
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )
拾香紀
by 陳慧
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)(374)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Lai
Lai added to library
香港道路探索
by 邱益彰
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)(2)

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

0

Reviews

Lai
Lai added to library
你看港街招牌
by 李健明
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(3)

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

Review

Have it in their library

0

Are reading it right now

Review

Lai
Lai added to library
花果飄零
by 周愛靈
(*)(*)(*)(*)( )(11)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Lai
Lai added to library
對倒
by 劉以鬯
(*)(*)(*)(*)(*)(132)

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Have it in their library

Are reading it right now

Reviews

Lai
Lai wrote a review
(*)(*)(*)( )( )
此書成書於2000年,當時香港人並沒有如今天般抗拒中共,作者已警惕中國史觀的香港史。作者看透了回歸前湧現的香港史的「現實作用」,並非為香港的殖民地時期著史,而是用作主導回歸時期的主流論述。 雖然全書主要戳破中國內地的歷史論述的政治原因,然而作者自身也受了影響,有一些前設沒有經過合理的反思。 < 香港人的定義 > 作者開首談及香港人的不同定義,廣義是指在香港的中國人,狹義是指具備本土意識的中國人或唐人。其實不少印歐種族,百年來已數代以香港為家,作者好像壓跟兒沒有想起他們。 < 香港與前代中國發展相連 > 作者首先指出,有香港史以新近出土古文物論證香港由始至終是中國一部份,作者認為這些論證並沒有說服力。因為上古文物和現代香港發展沒法扣連,上古文物沒有證明香港傳承中華文化五千年。 地域上,作者指出中國人 (或中原的人) 向來不認為嶺南人是中國人。中原政權向來視嶺南為四方蠻夷,化外之民,常以獵奇角度記述嶺南風土人民。時序上,英人到香港之前,傳統經濟活動 (採珠、製香、製鹽),早在康熙年間因遷界湮沒。 作者層層論證,指出前代中國發展,或是明清以前的香港,和現代香港的發展無法扣連。假如上古文物和現代香港發展沒有關係,明清以前的人事也同樣沒有關連。雖然作者指︰「經歷了二千年,我們完全不會懷疑香港是不是中國的一部份。」但上文下理的論述卻是與此相違背。